How to dispose of paint
Every garage has a shelf of paint cans from colors you no longer own walls in. How you get rid of them depends almost entirely on one word on the label: latex or oil.
Short answerDry out latex paint with a paint hardener, cat litter or sawdust, then trash it if your area allows that. Take oil-based and spray paint to a household hazardous waste drop-off. In Illinois and Minnesota, PaintCare sites take leftover paint free.
Prices and rules checked against each site's own page, linked below. They change, so call before a big load.
Check the can first
Latex and other water-based paints are treated differently from oil-based paint. SWACO, the solid waste authority for Columbus, says latex and water-based paints aren't considered hazardous, so they're left out of its free hazardous waste program. Oil-based paint, spray paint, stains and thinners are in it. Source
The label will tell you which one you have.
Latex paint: dry it out
SWACO's advice for leftover latex paint is to let it harden, then put it in the regular trash. Stir in a paint hardener from a hardware store, or use cat litter or sawdust, or just leave the lid off. SWACO warns it can take several days to solidify fully. Source
That's one county's guidance. Before you trash a dried can, check what your own county or trash hauler says.
If you'd rather hand it off, SWACO's hazardous waste contractor takes latex paint for a fee, and SWACO's Recycling Convenience Center lists latex, oil-based and spray paint among what it accepts from Franklin County residents (source).
Oil-based and spray paint: a hazardous waste drop-off
These go to a household hazardous waste site. SWACO's on East 8th Avenue in Columbus takes oil-based paint, spray paint, stains and thinners free from Franklin County residents. It's not open to businesses. SWACO lists the hours as Monday to Friday 9 AM to 5 PM and the first Saturday of the month 9 AM to 2 PM. Source
The Hamilton County, Indiana center takes paint from county residents, asks you to register your drop-off, and caps chemical waste, paint included, at 200 pounds per household a month. Source
Illinois and Minnesota: PaintCare
If you live in Illinois or Minnesota, there's an easier option. Both states have PaintCare, a paint stewardship program with drop-off sites where you can leave leftover paint at no charge. It's paid for by a fee added when paint is sold. Source
PaintCare sites take house paint, primers, stains, sealers and clear coatings like shellac and varnish, in original containers up to 5 gallons with the label still on and the lid secured. They don't take aerosols, solvents, thinners, auto or marine paint, art paints, or open or leaking cans. Source PaintCare has a drop-off site locator.
In the Midwest, those are the only two states with PaintCare. The rest of the program covers California, Colorado, Connecticut, Washington, D.C., Maine, Maryland, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont and Washington.
What the dump says
The Franklin County Sanitary Landfill takes nothing hazardous (source). Rumpke's Clermont County depot, the Taylor transfer station and the Westland Recycle Center all list paint as not accepted.
How to dispose of a mattress
How to dispose of batteries
How to dispose of a refrigerator or AC unit
How much does it cost to go to the dump?
Where can you dump for free?
What can't you take to the dump?